For the oral presentation, I am presenting information on Abraham Lincoln Brigade Veteran, Isidore (“Toots”) Irving Fajans. Although not that much information was presented about him in the online database of the archive, there was a decent amount of information to piece together the parts of Fajans life. To dissect his life, I will provide a quote found through my research and analysis for four different time periods: Pre-War, Spanish Civil War, World War II, Post-War.
Pre-War
“If you were caught distributing union literature around the job, you were instantly fired, We thought up ways of passing leaflets without the boss being able to pin anybody down. We swiped the key to the toilet paper dispensers in the washroom, took out the paper and substituted printed slips of just the right size! We got a lot of new members that way – it appealed to their sense of humor” (Jewish Americans).
Before the war, Fajans joined the Young Communist League as a manner to seek answers for the economic problems of the Great Depression. During the 1920s and the Depression, Fajans tried to persuade department store workers to join the Department Store Employees Union for better pay and working conditions. He used techniques to gain membership. The public was not supportive of striking workers and workers’ right since they saw strikes as unrest in society and people were trying to adjust back to peaceful living after World War I, so organization of unions had to be creative and more secretive.
Spanish Civil War
“Irv was a humanitarian in the very best tradition. The motives that inspired him to fight in Spain were the noblest. To fight for justice and brotherhood and peace is difficult, perilous, and often painful. To take part in such a fight is the very special mark of a very special breed of man. As a humanist and as a Jew, your father was the product of ancient and ageless traditions of struggle for impossible dreams” (Eulogy at Fajans’ funeral)
Fajans’ personality and political reasoning for fighting in Spain are emphasized in this eulogy at his funeral that is addressed to his two daughters. The “often painful” mention may refer to the fact that Fajans was severely wounded in Jarama and Brunete. The anti-semitism of fascism was alarming for Fajans (as a Jew) and he seemed to view religion with great importance in his life, for a later part in the eulogy compares Irv’s dedication to fight in Spain to the pride and honor associated with the Israeli army.
World War II
“In making inquiries up the chain of command, neither my company commander, battalion commander, nor my regimental commander knew whether I would be commissioned, or the reason for the delay… Previously I had been told that it was “very likely” that I would spend the duration at Fort McClellan… Officers with whom I have talked have told me that the reason for all this is ‘probably’ because I fought in the war in Spain. This unofficial opinion has served to explain. I cannot believe that that is the reason, as I cannot see how my fighting the Axis in Spain can have any detrimental effect on my value as a soldier in this war, in which we are fighting the same forces which enslaved the Spanish people.”
Although Veterans of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade had fought against fascism in Spain, many enlisted to fight Hitler and Mussolini in World War II; however, many A.L.B. veterans were discriminated against and their support of the Spanish Republic actually compromised their military status. Many were prohibited from promotion or from even participating in active duty, and the A.L. vets did not receive the postwar benefits that World War II veterans often received.
Fajans had written the quoted letter to the commander-in-chief of the U.S. Armed Forces that mentioned the possible discrimination he had received after completing his training at the top of his classes but not receiving orders to see action. Fajans goes on to talk about how he is proud that he fought in Spain for he was able to see the horrific intentions of the fascist powers back in 1937, yet doesn’t understand how this could have a negative effect on him as a soldier.
It turns out that the U.S. feared the Lincoln vets association with communist ideologies. The military often didn’t believe that American volunteers realistically went to Spain to fight fascism in 1937, but rather, they believed it was due to their desire to promote communism, also asking ALB Veterans questions like, “What would you do if the United States went to war with Russia?” As a result of this, many veterans of the Spanish conflict received much discrimination during the Second World War and the post-war.
Post-War
After the war, Fajans served as an executive secretary to the Veterans of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade (VALB) and as an editor of a literary collection on the Spanish Civil War called The Heart of Spain. He resigned as editor since Communist leaders persuaded the VALB to not include a work by Ernest Hemingway that paid homage to those who lost their lives in Spain since it had criticized the communist party leaders. Fajans then moved onto filmmaking, using the GI Bill (1944 bill that provided benefits for WWII veterans including expenses to further their education) to learn about the field. Fajans joined blacklisted filmmakers (communist sympathies often complicated employment in Hollywood) and produced Salt of the Earth, a documentary on a zinc mine worker strike in New Mexico. The film was seen as revolutionary and helped advance the feminist political and social point of view in a neorealist manner. (Neorealism was a form of art and film that focused more on daily life and the struggles of the working class – Fajans can relate since grew up in working-class Brooklyn)
Fajans unfortunately died prematurely in 1968 at the age of 52 due to a heart attack, leaving behind his wife, Muriel, and his two daughters, Jane and Betsy. However, in a span of 52 years, Fajans accomplished more than most can hope to achieve and his pride in fighting in the Spanish Civil War is remarkable due to the discrimination he and other VALB members received.